Legal bases: Yugoslavia

 

RULES OF PROCEDURE FOR THE OMBUDSPERSON
INSTITUTION IN KOSOVO

 

PREAMBLE

The Ombudsperson,  

Pursuant to the authority given to him/her under UNMIK Regulation No. 2000/38 of 30 June 2000, On the Establishment of the Ombudsperson Institution in kosovo, Section 10, and,

Recalling:

  United Nations Security Council Resolution 1244 (1999) of 10 June 1999, in particular para. 11; Report of the Secretary-General on the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in kosovo of 12 July 1999 (S/1999/779), in particular para. 89-90;

  Decision 305 of 1 July 1999 of the OSCE (PC.DEC/305), in particular para. 4; and Report of the Secretary-General on the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in kosovo of 23 December 1999 (S/1999/1250), in particular para. 83,

Adopts the present Rules of Procedure:

INTRODUCTORY PROVISIONS

The right to complain to the Ombudsperson regarding violations of human rights and abuses of authority is guaranteed to all persons, irrespective of background, citizenship, ethnicity, nationality, gender, race, colour, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, association with a national minority, property, birth, age, sexual orientation, place of residence, legal incapacity, detention, relationship with any administrative authority or any other status. All services offered by the Ombudsperson Institution are free.

Definitions:

The terms hereby enumerated shall be understood as having the following meaning:

1. Applicant: Any individual, group of individuals, registered or not registered non­governmental organisation, or entity who/which claims that her/his/its rights have been violated or alleges to be a victim of an abuse of authority.

2. Application: A completed form that states a complaint of a human rights violation or an abuse of authority to which the Ombudsperson will respond.

3. Provisional Registration: The process of numerically listing applications received by the Ombudsperson.

4. Registration: The process of numerically listing applications that have been verified as admissible by the Ombudsperson.

5. Respondent Party: Any person or entity as defined by the Regulation against whom an application has been filed with the Ombudsperson or whom the Ombudsperson identifies ex officio as having had a possible role in the alleged violation or abuse.

6. Parties: The Applicant(s) and the Respondent Party/Parties.

7. Other Authority: Any authority/entity/group other than the Respondent Party, which during the investigation, appears to be in any way involved in a case before the Ombudsperson.

8. Representative: Any person authorised by the Applicant or by law to represent her/him throughout the procedures before the Ombudsperson.

Rule 1
Filing an Application

1. Applicants will fill out an application form provided by the Ombudsperson Institution with the assistance of an Ombudsperson Institution officer. The application form must be dated and signed by the Applicant and/or her/his Representative.

2. Legal representation through a lawyer is not needed.

3. An application should contain the following information:

a) full name, age, gender, ethnicity, occupation, marital status and citizenship of Applicant, and/or full name and registration information, if registered, of any Applicant(s) that is/are an organisation or entity;

b) home and/or work address of the Applicant, and the correspondence address, if different;

c) full name, occupation and contact address of the Representative of the Applicant, if any;

d) full name/title and contact address of the alleged Respondent Party or Parties if known by the Applicant. If not, sufficient other information to identify the Respondent Party or Parties;

e) full name of the officer of the Ombudsperson Institution assisting the Applicant;

f) a statement of the alleged facts, including date of incident;

g) a statement of the alleged human rights violation or alleged abuse of authority;

h) a statement of what the Applicant wants to achieve in that specific case;

i)   a list of the documents attached to the application, or in case they are not in the Applicants' possession, information as to where necessary documents can be found;

j)   an indication as to whether a similar complaint has been submitted to any domestic authority, any body of the Interim Civil Administration, or any international body and the outcome of such proceedings; and

k) a general preliminary comment by the officer assisting the Applicant on the case including a provisional classification of the alleged human rights violation(s).

4.   An authorisation of the Representative shall be attached if the Applicant files the complaint through a Representative or if the Applicant chooses to be represented during any stage of the procedures before the Ombudsperson.

5.   The application form may be filed in any of the languages used in the region or in English. All conclusions or assessments of the application will be available in English, Albanian and Serbian and another language, if the Ombudsperson so decides.

6.   The Applicant or her/his Representative shall inform the Ombudsperson of any changes of address or any circumstances relevant to the application.

Rule 2
Investigations Ex Officio

The Ombudsperson may conduct investigations on her/his own initiative on receiving information indicating that human rights violations or abuses of authority may have occurred. When deciding whether to open such an ex officio investigation, the Ombudsperson may consider information from any source.

Rule3
Provisional Registration and Notification of Receipt

1. The Ombudsperson shall provisionally register all applications received.

2. The Ombudsperson shall notify the Applicant of receipt of the Application as soon as possible.

Rule 4
Confidentiality and Classified Documents

1. Upon receipt of each application, the Applicant or the Representative will be asked whether she/he would like her/his/their names to be kept confidential.

2. The Ombudsperson Institution staff members who have access to confidential or classified information are bound not to disclose it to public or authorities.

3. All documents collected during the investigation of cases where discretion is

required, shall be registered as classified, either upon request by the Applicant or on the Ombudsperson's own initiative.

4. All classified documents shall be kept in a specially designated secured location.

5. Access to classified documents shall be limited to the investigators who are directly assigned to deal with the respective case and the Director for Investigations. Access of other staff to such documents may only take place when authorised by the Ombudsperson.

Rule 5
Conditions for Admissibility

1. The Ombudsperson shall verify the admissibility of the application.

2. The Ombudsperson shall not consider applications admissible if the application:

a. does not fall under the jurisdiction of Ombudsperson in accordance with the provisions of Section 3 of Regulation No. 2000/38 of 30 June 2000;

b. is manifestly ill-founded or constitutes an abuse of the right of petition;

c. has not been brought before the competent authorities in Kosovo and there are reasonable grounds to believe that such authority would provide an effective remedy;

d. is filed by an administrative or other authority and concerns facts under the jurisdiction of that same authority.

3. The Ombudsperson may, at her/his discretion, waive any of the conditions listed above, with the exception of condition 2a.

4. In order to verify the admissibility of an application, the Ombudsperson may conduct any necessary interviews or research.

Rule 6
Opening of a Case

1. Once admissibility is verified, the Ombudsperson will open an investigation of the case.

2. Following this decision, the case will be registered.

Rule 7
Informing the Applicant of the Ombudsperson's Decisions

1. When the Ombudsperson finds an application to be inadmissible, she/he shall inform the Applicant of the basis for that decision. When appropriate, the Ombudsperson shall also inform the Applicant of any possibilities to file a new or renewed application, for example, on the provision of new information, such as the exhaustion of other remedies or other means of redress falling outside the jurisdiction of the Ombudsperson.

2. If it has been decided that the application is admissible, the Ombudsperson shall notify the Applicant.

Rule 8
Registration of Investigations Ex Offlcio

When the Ombudsperson decides to conduct investigations by her/his own initiative, she/he makes a written decision including the grounds for that decision and this shall be registered as the basis for conducting investigations.

Rule 9
Decision to Strike a Case

1. The Ombudsperson may discontinue an investigation of a case if any of the circumstances provided in Rule 5 are present.

2. The Ombudsperson may discontinue an investigation if the Applicant so requests.

3. If the Ombudsperson decides to discontinue an investigation, she/he will notify the Applicant of this decision and its basis. In such cases the Ombudsperson will strike the case from the list of pending cases.

4. The Ombudsperson shall inform the Applicant of the possibility of having the case re­opened if the grounds for the decision to strike the case do no longer exist and/or new facts are presented to the Ombudsperson that justify renewing an investigations of the case.

Rule 10
Informing the Respondent Party/Parties

1. The Ombudsperson may inform the Respondent Party/Parties as soon as possible of the application and invite the Party/Parties to submit written information, observations and/or envisaged solutions. The Respondent Party/Parties may also be required to submit specific documents.

2. The Ombudsperson sets the time limit within which the Respondent Party/Parties shall comply with requests of the Ombudsperson.

3. Should the Respondent Party/Parties fail to respond, the Ombudsperson may pursue the investigation on the basis of other information available.

4. In special circumstances, the Ombudsperson may decide to initiate investigations in a case without seeking information and/or observations and/or envisaged solutions from the Respondent Party/Parties.

Rule 11
Other Authorities

1. If investigations suggest that any authority other than the Respondent Party /Parties are in any way involved in a case, the Ombudsperson may contact the respective authority at any time during the investigations.

2. The Ombudsperson may decide to qualify the respective authority as Respondent Party/Parties and to follow the procedure provided above.

Rule 12
Informing the Applicant of the Respondent Party's Submissions

1. The Ombudsperson may inform the Applicant of the submission of the Respondent Party/Parties and may give the Applicant the opportunity to reply to the issues raised by the former.

2. The Ombudsperson may require the Applicant to reply within a time limit set by the Ombudsperson.

3. Should the Applicant fail to reply, the Ombudsperson may pursue the investigations. However, a failure to respond may be considered as a loss of interest and it may justify the termination of the investigation.

Rule 13
Investigations and Preferential Assistance

1. At any time during the investigations, the Ombudsperson may interview witnesses.

2.  If civil servants refuse or are prevented from being interviewed the Ombudsperson may ask for explanatory letters and may address the issue hierarchically.

3. All persons and entities subject to the jurisdiction of the Ombudsperson are required to provide the Ombudsperson with preferential assistance. The staff acting on behalf of the Ombudsperson shall benefit of the same preferential assistance.

4. The Ombudsperson may ask for assistance from the police and KFOR if it is necessary to secure an investigation or to protect Applicants, witnesses or any other person/entity in any way involved in the investigations by the Ombudsperson, including the Ombudsperson and the staff of the Institution.

5. If preferential assistance is denied the Ombudsperson may notify the highest authority with jurisdiction over the matter.

Rule 14
Access to Files and Documents and Inspections

1. At any time during the investigations the Ombudsperson may ask individuals, governmental authorities or private entities to co-operate by providing relevant information, files and documents including those classified as secret or confidential. They shall provide all the information and assistance requested by the Ombudsperson.

2. In order to ensure that her/his access to documents is not hindered, the Ombudsperson may effectuate routine inspections to any authority under her/his jurisdiction.

3. All authorities under the jurisdiction of the Ombudsperson shall permit the Ombudsperson access to their premises, allowing her/him to move within the premises without restriction to acquire documents, interview witnesses or carry out any other activities necessary to the investigation.

4. The Ombudsperson may require copies of any of the above mentioned documents be provided by the relevant authority or agency.

5. If civil servants refuse or are prevented from providing the above mentioned information, documents or files, the Ombudsperson may ask for an explanatory letter and may address the issue hierarchically.

6. If the Special Representative of the Secretary General exercises his power to refuse the release of a document or a file, as provided by Section 4.7 of Regulation No. 2000/38, the Ombudsperson may draw such inferences as she/he sees fit from the refusal and address such refusal in her/his special or annual report.

7. If requested, the Ombudsperson and/or her/his staff shall undertake a duty of discretion with regard to the classified information or documents. The duty of discretion shall continue after the person concerned leaves office or ceases employment with the Institution.

8. The Ombudsperson may at any time enter and inspect any place where people are deprived from their liberty or where freedom of movement is restricted (e.g. detention centre, police lock-up, house arrest, psychiatric or other hospital).

9. The Ombudsperson may interview in private persons deprived of their liberty and take part in any meeting or hearing involving such persons.

Rule 15
Ombudsperson's Assistance

The Ombudsperson may at any stage during an investigation be assisted by any person deemed necessary, such as the Applicant, the Respondent Party/Parties and/or their Representatives, interpreters and legal, forensic, financial or other experts.

Rule 16
Interim Measures and Suspension of Administrative Decisions

1. At any time during an investigation the Ombudsperson may recommend that the respondent Party/Parties or any other authority adopt an interim measure she/he deems necessary for the immediate protection of the rights and freedoms of the Applicant or for the safety of the Applicant and witnesses.

2. During an investigation the Ombudsperson may recommend the respondent Party/Parties to suspend the execution of an administrative or disciplinary decision if such an execution may result in irreparable prejudice for the rights of the Applicant.

3. The Ombudsperson may ask the responsible authorities to implement the requested interim measure and sets the time limit within the respondent Part/Parties shall comply with requests of the Ombudsperson.

4. An interim measure taken in accordance with para. 1 and 2 shall stay in force until an investigation is concluded or until the Ombudsperson decides on its termination.

5. The Ombudsperson shall inform the Parties and other authorities of a recommendation made under para. 1 and 2 and on the response of the authority to whom the recommendation was addressed.

Rule 17
Good Offices

1. The Ombudsperson may at any stage during an investigation offer her/his good offices, for example mediation and reconciliation, and place herself/himself at the disposal of the Parties with a view to secure a friendly settlement of the matter on the basis of respect for human rights as defined in the internationally recognised standards.

2. When a friendly settlement is reached, the obligation undertaken by the Parties, the time limits for their fulfilment and any other circumstances relevant for the case shall be included in a written agreement.

3. The Ombudsperson shall terminate an investigation and close the case when she/he is satisfied that the Parties fulfilled the commitments undertaken in the written agreement as a part of the friendly settlement.

4. The Ombudsperson may also offer her/his good offices with regard to cases involving persons from Kosovo outside of its territory.

Rule 18
Case-report

Once an investigation is concluded the Ombudsperson will issue a case-report that includes the recommendations, if any.

Rule 19
Recommendations

1. If the Ombudsperson finds any of the violations or abuses of authority derived from in Sections 1 and 3 of Regulation No. 2000/38, she/he shall make recommendations to the Respondent Party/Parties about appropriate measures to take, and shall specify a time limit for the fulfilment of them. The limit may be extended if the Ombudsperson deems it necessary.

2. The Ombudsperson may recommend to the competent authorities that disciplinary or criminal proceedings be initiated against any person.

3. If the Ombudsperson finds that any authority other than the Respondent Party/Parties has indirectly contributed to a breach, she/he may recommend that the respective authority adopt any appropriate measures deemed necessary.

4. The Ombudsperson shall notify the Applicant on her/his recommendations and on the response of the Respondent Party/Parties or of other authorities involved.

5. The Ombudsperson may make recommendations to amend the existing domestic legislation or to adopt new legislation in order to ensure the compatibility of the legal system with the recognised international human rights standards.

Rule 20
Monitoring / Closing the case

1. Once recommendations have been made by the Ombudsperson, if the administrative authorities or officials concerned do not take appropriate measures within a reasonable time, or if they do not provide the Ombudsperson with reasons for not doing so that are acceptable to the Ombudsperson, the Ombudsperson may draw the Special Representatives of the Secretary-General's attention to the matter and may make a public statement thereon.

2. Once the Ombudsperson has decided that the monitoring period is over, either

because her/his recommendations were implemented or she/he took measures according to para. 1, the case will be closed.

Rule 21
Publishing the Case-reports and Recommendations

1. The Ombudsperson shall make public her/his case-reports, save in cases which she/he considers to contain confidential information, or where the applicant has expressly requested that her/his/its identity and the circumstances of the complaint are not to be revealed.

2. All case-reports and recommendations will be available in English, Albanian, Serbian and another language, if the Ombudsperson so decides.

Rule 22
Annual and Special Reports

1. The Ombudsperson shall provide an annual report to the Special Representative of the Secretary-General covering the activities during the complete year starting 30 June.

2. The annual report shall be submitted to the Special Representative of the Secretary General no later than 30 November.

3. The Ombudsperson may issue a special report whenever she/he deems it appropriate.

4. The Ombudsperson shall make public the reports.

5. Annual and special reports will be available in English, Albanian, Serbian and another language, if the Ombudsperson so decides.

Rule 23
Languages

1. The Rules of Procedure are published in English, Albanian and Serbian.  The authentic version shall be the English language version.

2. The Rules of Procedure and any amendments to it shall be translated into any other language in use within the territory of Kosovo, if the Ombudsperson deems it necessary.

Rule 24
Amending the Rules of Procedure

The Ombudsperson may at any time amend the Rules of Procedures following consultation with the Deputy Ombudspersons.

Rule 25
Forwarding Rules of Procedure and Subsequent Amendments

The Rules of Procedure and any subsequent amendments shall be forwarded to the Special Representative of the Secretary General, Head of the OSCE Mission in Kosovo, as well as any relevant local institutions. They shall be accessible to the public.

Rule 26
Entry into force

The Rules of Procedure shall enter into force on 21 November 2000.

Adopted 20 November 2000 following consultation with the Deputy Ombudspersons.

Marek Antoni Nowicki

Ombudsperson